How Does a Hot Market Affect Appraisals?



Want to sell your home? Get a FREE home value report
Want to buy a home? Search all homes for sale

Our marketplace is currently experiencing rising prices. Likewise, an appreciating market leads to challenges with appraisals. In the last month, I had this situation come up five times. Prior to this year, I probably saw it five times in nine years of selling homes.


Recently, we sold a home in Idaho Falls. After we conducted a market analysis, the home was worth somewhere around $145,000. However, with all the work they’ve done on the property, we ended up listing it at $159,000. The sellers accepted a full-price offer within a few weeks!

The appraiser came back with $153,000 valuation on that house, even though it sold for more. In situations like this, the buyer can walk away if they’re not pleased with the listing price. Their lender might only loan up to a certain percentage as well. On the flipside, because buyers have limited options, you have a higher likelihood to walk away with top dollar.

When you aggressively price a home, it’s a matter of finding a buyer willing to buy it. Sometimes, there will be a dissonance with the appraiser's judgment. However, that’s only one perspective and everyone looks at home values differently. Some buyers are extremely limited and will pay the price for the features they want.

If you’re thinking about buying or selling a home in Idaho Falls or the surrounding area, give us a call or send us an email. We’d be happy to help you and answer any real estate questions you might have!

Idaho Falls Real Estate Market Update



Want to sell your home? Get a FREE home value report
Want to buy a home? Search all homes for sale

Last year at this time, we had a 4.9 month supply of inventory. Five to seven months of inventory is considered a balanced market, and anything under five is considered a seller’s market. So in 2015, we had just crossed the line into a seller’s market, and we have stayed there ever since. Today, there is only a 2.7 month supply of homes on the market, which is a very strong seller’s market. There is a shortage of homes available.

The good news for sellers is that the current list to sales price ratio is 99.6%, meaning sellers are netting almost all of the asking price. Buyer concessions are not calculated into that ratio, but this is still great news if you’re a seller. The market can be a bit challenging if you’re a buyer but there are still some great deals out there. If you work with the right agent, you can still find a property at a good price. Last year, the list to sales price ratio was 98.14%.


Homes are selling faster than they were last year, too. In 2015, the average days on market was 92, and this year, homes are on the market for an average of 75 days. That’s a significant drop.

The average sales price in Bonneville is up from $155,000 in 2015 to $172,000 this year. Those numbers do not reflect the exact amount of appreciation in our market, as the average sales price is pulled up due to the growing number of sold luxury homes. However, we have definitely seen about 7% to 8% appreciation in the last 12 months.

If you’re a buyer, it’s critical to have an agent looking for properties for you every morning. Although it might seem easy to sell in this market, you still need a professional on your side to maximize what you get out of your house.

If you have any questions, give us a call or send us an email. We would be happy to help you!